{"id":48547,"date":"2022-03-24T09:02:46","date_gmt":"2022-03-24T14:02:46","guid":{"rendered":"http:\/\/www.davidbordwell.net\/blog\/?p=48547"},"modified":"2022-03-25T13:37:54","modified_gmt":"2022-03-25T18:37:54","slug":"oscars-siren-song-the-revenge","status":"publish","type":"post","link":"https:\/\/www.davidbordwell.net\/blog\/2022\/03\/24\/oscars-siren-song-the-revenge\/","title":{"rendered":"Oscar’s siren song: The revenge"},"content":{"rendered":"

\"\"<\/a><\/p>\n

King Richard<\/em><\/strong><\/p>\n

The Oscars are upon us again. The Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences may have decided that “Music (Original Score)” is one of the categories not important enough to show live along with the rest of the awarding of the golden statuettes. We, of course, think this is absurd. (Will the Oscar ceremony gain a single extra TV viewer through this tactic?)<\/em><\/p>\n

We welcome back our friend and colleague Jeff Smith<\/strong> to continue his annual comments and predictions concerning the nominees in both musical categories: song and original score. This year he has, if anything, outdone himself in providing insights into the historical contexts and the formal qualities of the ten nominees.<\/em><\/p>\n

 <\/p>\n

\u2018Tis the season to pass out little gold men to people in gowns and tuxedos. This year\u2019s Oscar ceremony is scheduled to take place on Sunday night, March 27th<\/sup>.\u00a0 And this is about the time when I offer my annual assessment of the nominees in the music categories.<\/p>\n

The title I\u2019ve given this blog post might appear to represent a failure of imagination. After posting the first of these surveys, I opted for a sequelitis motif by using Roman numerals and corny words like \u201cReturn.\u201d Yet this year\u2019s sequel title seems all too apt.\u00a0 The producers of the Academy Awards have been winnowing away the amount of airtime given to the music awards in the past two years. They no longer present all five of the Best Original Song nominees as part of the broadcast. This year the award for Original Score will be prerecorded before the broadcast and the winner announced in between other, presumably more important awards.<\/p>\n

If the Academy Awards doesn\u2019t seem to care about these categories, then why should I? Well, because as a scholar and educator, this is what I do. Consider this blog post the petty revenge of someone who believes these categories still matter, even if the organization sponsoring the awards doesn\u2019t seem to think so.<\/p>\n

In the case of the award for Best Original Score, there will be some bitter irony in the fact that we\u2019ll never see the faces of the composers on the big five-way split screen used to show nominees. But we\u2019ll hear their scores played as walk-up music if Penelope Cruz wins for Best Actress. Or if Greig Fraser wins for Best Cinematography. Or Encanto<\/em> wins for Best Animated Film. Or Jane Campion wins for Best Director. Or Adam McKay wins for Best Original Screenplay.<\/p>\n

At the end of each award preview, I\u2019ll make an educated guess as to who the winner of the category will be. All the usual caveats apply. These predictions are not intended for wagering purposes, I offer the usual disclosure that my predictions over the years typically yield one right and one wrong. (It\u2019s up to you to figure out which is which.)<\/p>\n

Lastly, a warning of some spoilers<\/strong>.\u00a0 I do my best to try to avoid giving away too much information about a film.\u00a0 But sometimes it is unavoidable if you want to get into the nitty gritty of the choices composers make in how they score their films.<\/p>\n

 <\/p>\n

The Susan Lucci of songwriting<\/strong><\/p>\n

\"\"<\/a><\/p>\n

Last month, Diane Warren earned her 13th<\/sup> Oscar nomination for Best Original Song, the most by a woman in any category without a win.\u00a0 This isn\u2019t the most, though, in the music categories as composers Thomas Newman and Alex North both earned 15 nominations for Best Score without ever taking home Oscar. Last April, Warren told Billboard<\/em> that she the old saw about it being \u201cnice to be nominated\u201d was true, but that she really would like to finally win an Oscar.\u00a0 Said Warren, \u201cI\u2019m like a sports team that has lost the World Series for decades.\u00a0 This is 33 years since my first nomination.\u201d Warren\u2019s record begs comparison with soap opera star Susan Lucci, who earned 18 Daytime Emmy nominations for her role as Erica Kane on All My Children<\/em> before finally winning the award in 1999.<\/p>\n

Warren\u2019s current nomination is for her song, \u201cSomehow You Do,\u201d which is featured in Rodrigo Garcia\u2019s drama about opioid addiction, Four Good Days<\/em>. Sung by Reba McEntire, Warren\u2019s number is a countrified version of the sort of power ballad that the tunesmith has specialized in for decades. The first verse is modestly arranged for two guitars, one an acoustic and the other pedal steel. The song <\/a>gradually adds more texture as it nears the chorus, with the bass adding some bottom end and a chorus punching up McEntire\u2019s lead vocal.<\/p>\n

The second verse continues to build with the addition of a drum kit that firmly establishes the song\u2019s 6\/8 meter and slow tempo. The song\u2019s bridge introduces a contrasting melody and roughens up the sweetness of McEntire\u2019s voice with some pulsating power chords played by an electric guitar. This prepares for the requisite key change as the song shifts to the final verse and chorus. The tune reaches its emotional peak here and then gradually tapers down. A brief coda returns us to the spare sound of McEntire\u2019s voice accompanied by an acoustic guitar.<\/p>\n

The song is very well-crafted if a bit by the numbers. It is a testament to Warren\u2019s mastery of her craft that she finds new ways to enliven the venerable AABA structure of classic songs and fit them to the dramatic needs of the films she works on.<\/p>\n

Yet Warren\u2019s chances of winning seem to be hampered by a couple of factors. If you asked yourself, \u201cWhat is Four Good Days<\/em>?\u201d, you are not alone. The film garnered little attention from critics and fans, earning less than $900,000 during its theatrical release.\u00a0 Moreover, although McEntire is a huge star in the world of country music, that probably won\u2019t cut much ice for voters in the Academy music branch who represent a different industry demographic.<\/p>\n

There seems little doubt that Warren has a dedicated following within the music branch.\u00a0 However, although it is big enough to consistently yield nominations, it isn\u2019t large enough to deliver the big prize. Warren likely will have to content herself with \u201cIt\u2019s nice to be nominated.\u201d\u00a0 If she starts to feel too downhearted, Warren can console herself by looking at her royalty statements for \u201cRhythm of the Night.\u201d Or \u201cI Don\u2019t Want to Miss a Thing.\u201d Or \u201cHow Do I Live.\u201d\u00a0 (You get the idea\u2026)<\/p>\n

 <\/p>\n

The Legends (and I don\u2019t mean John, Chrissy, Luna, and Miles)<\/strong><\/p>\n

\u00a0\"\"<\/a><\/strong><\/p>\n

The next two nominees are among pop music\u2019s biggest icons, representing more than ninety years of combined experience in the biz.\u00a0 A bit surprisingly, though, both artists also are first-time Oscar nominees.<\/p>\n

First up is the man who epitomizes Northern Soul: Irish singer and songwriter Van Morrison. Morrison is nominated for \u201cDown to Joy\u201d from Kenneth Branagh\u2019s Belfast<\/em>. Like Branagh, Morrison was born and raised in Belfast. He also has been closely associated with the city throughout his career, receiving the monikers of \u201cthe Belfast Cowboy\u201d and \u201cthe Belfast Lion.\u201d\u00a0 The early peak of Morrison\u2019s career also coincides with the onset in 1969 of \u201cthe Troubles\u201d depicted in Belfast<\/em>. Besides \u201cDown to Joy,\u201d Branagh selected eight other Morrison tracks for the film\u2019s soundtrack, many of them lesser-known tracks like \u201cCaledonia Swing\u201d and \u201cCarrickfergus.\u201d By digging deep into Morrison\u2019s catalog, Branagh is not only able to provide a musical biography of his childhood, but also indicates how deeply Van the Man\u2019s music was woven into the fabric of everyday life in Belfast<\/a>.<\/p>\n

Morrison\u2019s \u201cDown to Joy\u201d also shows the durability of AABA form, albeit in this case channeling the sound of his early mid-tempo rockers like \u201cCaravan\u201d and \u201cDomino.\u201d The latter recordings are among the songs that would cement Morrison\u2019s status as a Celtic interpreter of the revue style of sixties soul music, especially the Stax sound epitomized by singers such as Solomon Burke, Wilson Pickett, Sam and Dave, and Otis Redding. Morrison based his entire career on melding those influences with more native elements of Irish folk music. For nearly sixty years, Morrison has demonstrated that the idiom of sixties soul seems almost timeless, an impression confirmed by even more modern practitioners, like Sharon Jones & the Dap Kings or Nathaniel Rateliff & the Night Sweats.<\/p>\n

Appearing over the end credits, \u201cDown to Joy\u201d neatly encapsulates the overall tone of Belfast<\/em> and its mix of nostalgia, melancholy, and hope. At the end of Belfast<\/em>, young Buddy and his family have been displaced by \u201cthe Troubles,\u201d forced to relocate by threats of IRA retaliation.\u00a0 Their journey to England is colored by the pain of family separation. Yet it also represents a horizon of new possibilities. \u201cDown to Joy\u201d reflects that latter sentiment with lyrics describing a new morning after a dark night, and the glory and gratitude expressed through Buddy\u2019s child-like naivete.<\/p>\n

So, what are the chances that Van the Man wraps his hands around a small golden dude?\u00a0 Not very good, if you ask me.<\/p>\n

Don\u2019t get me wrong!\u00a0 Morrison albums of the late sixties and seventies \u2013 Astral Weeks, Moondance, Tupelo Honey, Saint Dominic\u2019s Preview <\/em>\u2013 are stone cold classics.\u00a0 It\u2019s Too Late to Stop Now <\/em>is among the finest live albums ever recorded.\u00a0 Morrison\u2019s \u201cBrown Eyed Girl\u201d is my wife\u2019s very favorite song ever!<\/p>\n

I\u2019m a Van fan, but his public statements about the United Kingdom\u2019s Coronavirus restrictions have probably killed his chances of winning an Oscar. If younger members of the Academy know Morrison at all, it is likely as a conspiracy crank who is now recording with equally obnoxious anti-vaxxer Eric Clapton. I just can\u2019t see Academy voters giving Morrison a platform to air his views on social distancing and lockdowns. If they did, it would produce the kinds of news clips and headlines that the Academy would like to avoid. Just imagine the public response to an acceptance speech in which the boos from the crowd rain down on the winner. I imagine that a lot of folks in the music branch just can\u2019t bring themselves to vote for Morrison in the current political landscape. And, even as a lifelong fan, I can\u2019t really blame them.<\/p>\n

\"\"<\/a><\/p>\n

The third nominee for Best Original Song is \u201cBe Alive\u201d by DIXSON and Beyonc\u00e9 Knowles Carter.\u00a0 The song appears in the end credits of King Richard<\/em>, the biopic about Richard Williams, the father of tennis phenoms Serena and Venus. The tone of the music and lyrics<\/a> succeed in doing something the film itself struggles to do, namely give voice to the two women who end up rewriting the record books of professional tennis.<\/p>\n

In contrast, King Richard <\/em>casts Williams the elder as a Svengali figure shepherding his young prodigies into the world of big-time sports. He acts as the girls\u2019 agent, manager, coach, and protector, shielding Serena and Venus from the sorts of predations that characterize an industry with a bad reputation for chewing up and spitting out young talent. The lyrics of \u201cBe Alive\u201d speak to the family\u2019s sense of fierce independence and Williams\u2019 own \u201cbootstrap\u201d mentality.\u00a0 This is evident in couplets like:<\/p>\n

Couldn\u2019t wipe this black off if I tried<\/em><\/p>\n

That\u2019s why I lift my head with pride<\/em><\/p>\n

Later, Beyonc\u00e9 sings the praises of sisterhood, a theme that can be heard in some of her biggest hits, such as \u201cSingle Ladies (Put a Ring on It)\u201d or \u201cIndependent Women Part I,\u201d the latter recorded as a member of Destiny\u2019s Child.<\/p>\n

With its steady marching tempo borrowed from the Doors\u2019 \u201cFive to One\u201d and Beyonc\u00e9\u2019s soaring vocals, \u201cBe Alive\u201d bespeaks a mood of strength and defiance. Yet, it isn\u2019t as well placed as some of the other songs in the category and, unlike many of Beyonc\u00e9\u2019s popular records, it also isn\u2019t the kind of earworm that lights up record charts. \u201cBe Alive\u201d peaked at #40 in Billboar<\/em>d\u2019s Hot 100, likely a disappointment considering how well King Richard <\/em>has performed in other audience metrics.<\/p>\n

Come Sunday, I suspect that Beyonc\u00e9 will likely go home empty handed.\u00a0 Like Diane Warren, she\u2019ll need to console herself with the mantra \u201cIt\u2019s nice to be nominated\u201d and the many other Grammys, ASCAP, Billboard<\/em>, BET, MTV, and American Music Awards that line her trophy case.<\/p>\n

 <\/p>\n

The Young Bloods<\/strong><\/p>\n

The final two nominees had big years in the world of entertainment in 2021. An Oscar would put a capper on a period of creative ferment that\u2019s the envy of most singers and songwriters. Yet, for these two performers, it just seems like another day at the office.<\/p>\n

Lin-Manuel Miranda received his second Oscar nomination for \u201cDos Oruguitas,\u201d one of several songs he wrote for the Disney animated musical Encanto<\/em>. The song is performed by Columbian singer Sebasti\u00e1n Yatra and appears in a flashback that dramatizes Abuela Alma\u2019s tragic backstory. As a young woman, Alma, her husband Pedro, and their triplets attempt to escape their village after war breaks out. During their journey, they are beset by armed horsemen. The refugees scatter, but Pedro is killed when he halts the charging caballeros, presumably to ask for mercy for himself and his family. A candle Alma is holding protects the rest of the group, and its magical properties transform their future home into the \u201cCasita,\u201d<\/a> a fantastic space where its denizens are revealed to have supernatural abilities and the house has a mind of its own.<\/p>\n

\"\"<\/a>\u00a0\u00a0 \"\"<\/a><\/p>\n

\"\"<\/a>\u00a0\u00a0 \"\"<\/a><\/p>\n

The sequence itself is reminiscent of similar moments from films made by Disney\u2019s friendly rival, Pixar. The montage that encapsulates an entire life in a couple of minutes of screen time recalls the opening of Up <\/em>(2008) which depicts the long, happy marriage of Carl and Ellie until her illness and untimely death. The song that accompanies a flashback explaining the source of a character\u2019s trauma and grief is also seen in Toy Story 2<\/em>. Cowgirl Jessie relates how she once was her owner Emily\u2019s favorite doll, but ends up forgotten and left behind when Emily grows up. This is all set to the strains of Sarah McLachlan\u2019s \u201cWhen She Loved Me.\u201d The montage from Encanto <\/em>nicely fuses together both these narrative devices but gives them a Latin pop spin.<\/p>\n

Like \u201cSomehow You Do,\u201d \u201cDos Oruguitas\u201d begins quietly with a brief introduction played on an acoustic guitar. The slight syncopation of the guitar figure, though, gives it a bit of Hispanic flair.\u00a0 As Yatra\u2019s voice enters, the song\u2019s chord structure follows a chromatically descending bass line, a device that heightens the harmonic tension until it circles back to the tonic. The tune pauses briefly as Abuela confesses her guilt for forgetting what the purpose of the magic was for.\u00a0 Mirabel reassures her that the Madrigal family\u2019s entire livelihood is due to the earlier sacrifices the Abuela made and the suffering she endured.\u00a0 When they embrace, \u201cDos Oruguitas\u201d kicks back in with a slightly faster tempo and with fuller orchestration that includes strings, percussion, a chorus, and a harp. With the rift between Alma and Mirabel healed, the Madrigals band together to rebuild the \u201cCasita.\u201d The harmony created by the restored family bonds allows it to regain its sentient properties.<\/p>\n

As an Oscar nominee, \u201cDos Oruguitas\u201d has a lot going for it. It accompanies a very emotional scene of intergenerational reconciliation. It is a featured track on the Encanto <\/em>soundtrack, which has spent the past nine weeks atop Billboard<\/em>\u2019s Top 200 album chart. And Lin-Manuel Miranda is on a roll having served as the director of Tick, Tick…Boom!<\/em>, the musical biopic of Rent <\/em>composer Jonathan Larson, and as the producer of In the Heights<\/em>, the screen adaptation of Miranda\u2019s own hit Broadway play.<\/p>\n

Perhaps the only thing working against it is the fact that it\u2019s been overshadowed by another song from Encanto<\/em>. \u201cWe Don\u2019t Talk About Bruno\u201d is a certified pop culture sensation, spending five weeks as the #1 song on Billboard<\/em>\u2019s Hot 100, accumulating more than 300 million views on Vevo, and featured in 21 different languages on Instagram. Did Disney submit the wrong song for nomination? Maybe, but \u201cDos Oruguitas\u201d still might been benefit from the reflected glory of its more popular sibling. This and the fact that Encanto<\/em> is up for some other major awards have kept Miranda among the frontrunners.<\/p>\n

The last nominee is the title song from the most recent entry in the venerable James Bond series, No Time to Die<\/em>. The tune is performed by Billie Eilish and written by Eilish and her frequent songwriting partner, brother Finneas. Like Miranda, 2021 has been a good year for Eilish. Her new album Happier Than Ever <\/em>topped the charts in 26 countries across the globe, including the US.\u00a0 It also earned two Grammy awards and landed on several year-end \u201cbest of\u201d lists. In addition to her music, Eilish also appeared in two films: a concert film featuring songs from Happier Than Ever<\/em> and a \u201cbehind the scenes\u201d documentary distributed by Neon and Apple TV+ called Billie Eilish: The World\u2019s a Little Blurry<\/em>.<\/p>\n

In some respects, Eilish seems like an exemplary contributor to the amazing catalog of songs written for the Bond canon. She is an immensely popular artist. She is also someone who could update the template for the series by adding emo, dream-pop, and electro-pop touches to the usual Bond formula.<\/p>\n

In other respects, though, Eilish represents something of a departure from previous Bond songstresses. When one thinks of iconic Bond songs, one thinks of tunes like \u201cGoldfinger,\u201d \u201cDiamonds Are Forever,\u201d \u201cLicence to Kill,\u201d \u201cGoldeneye,\u201d \u201cThe World is Not Enough,\u201d \u201cSkyfall,\u201d and \u201cAnother Way to Die.\u201d\u00a0 What do these songs all have in common? They are all sung by women with big voices, belters like Gladys Knight, Tina Turner, Adele, Alicia Keys, and the two Shirleys: Bassey and Manson. In contrast, Eilish is known for a much softer style of singing: hushed, sensitive, and intimate. That seems fitting for a performer whose best-known album was inspired by lucid dreaming and night terrors. Yet it seems less well-suited for an almost mythic film character defined by his swagger, toughness, and even a streak of cruelty.<\/p>\n

Yet, if there was moment to rethink the traits of the typical Bond song, this was certainly it.\u00a0 In retrospect, the selection of Eilish was a masterstroke by the Bond brain trust led by Barbara Broccoli, the current head of Eon Productions. As the last film to feature Daniel Craig as James Bond, No Time to Die <\/em>not only caps off his five-film arc, but also serves as a reflexive meditation on the series as a whole. At one level, the explicit meaning of No Time to Die<\/em> is both simple and banal: everyone dies. Yet, by making references to several earlier films in the series, the accumulated weight of intertextual resonances invests the many deaths that occur in No Time to Die<\/em> with an unusual sense of depth and gravity.<\/p>\n

No Time to Die<\/em> begins with a scene where Bond visits the tomb of Vesper Lynd, the fellow agent featured in Casino Royale<\/em> who helps Bond defeat the evil Le Chiffre. Lynd and Bond fall in love, but she proves to be a double agent working for a rival operative. At film\u2019s end, Lynd sacrifices herself when she drowns in a locked elevator car that has submerged.<\/p>\n

\"\"<\/a><\/p>\n

M then reveals that she was an unwilling accomplice, a victim of blackmail after her previous boyfriend was abducted and threatened.<\/p>\n

Bond\u2019s pilgrimage to Lynd\u2019s grave presages several additional deaths in the film. Bond\u2019s best friend, CIA Agent Felix Leiter, and his mortal enemy, Ernst Stavro Blofeld, are killed in separate incidents. Even Bond himself perishes in the climax of No Time to Die<\/em>. He sacrifices himself to foil a scheme by Lyutsifer Safin to unleash a bioweapon upon the world that is transmitted by touch and kills its victims based upon their DNA. After a missile strike is launched against Safin\u2019s compound, Bond stays behind to assure that the silo\u2019s blast-proof doors stay open. Bond\u2019s gesture that not only saves the world but allows his current paramour, Madeleine Swann, and the young daughter he never knew he had, to safely escape the island.<\/p>\n

Given how much of No Time to Die <\/em>is pervaded by a sense of grief and sorrow, the decision to include a title song reflective of the film\u2019s solemnity and melancholy makes perfect sense. Like some of the other nominees, Eilish\u2019s tune <\/a>begins slowly and quietly with a piano plunking out a repeated four note motif accompanied by strings and low brass. Eilish intones the first lyric, \u201cI should have known\u201d in a sung whisper. The serpentine melody unwinds through the verse and chorus, eventually taking Eilish into the upper range of her soprano on the lines:<\/p>\n

Fool me once, fool me twice<\/em><\/p>\n

Are you death or paradise?<\/em><\/p>\n

You\u2019ll never see me cry<\/em><\/p>\n

There\u2019s just no time to die<\/em><\/p><\/blockquote>\n

Just as the chorus ends, a thunderous bass chord enters, and the opening four note motif returns. The song continues to build, and more instruments are added as the song reaches its second chorus. Our four-note motif returns once more, but this time played in full orchestral splendor by the strings and the full brass section. The musical bombast ultimately fulfills the remit of other classic Bond songs. Eilish even follows suit by loudly belting out the chorus, revealing a power and huskiness to her voice that most of her fans probably hadn\u2019t heard before.<\/p>\n

\u201cNo Time to Die\u201d finishes with a coda that returns to the sparse arrangement of the tune heard at the start. Eilish also goes back to the shivery murmur that is her stock in trade for one last iteration of the chorus\u2019 last two lines.<\/p>\n

No Time to Die<\/em> larger themes of love, death, grief, and martyrdom presented a special challenge. Billie and Finneas rise to it beautifully. Moreover, the Eilishes also cleverly incorporate musical elements that evoke the harmonies and tonalities of John Barry\u2019s best-known scores in the series. The four-note motif that serves as a spine for the song sounds like it could have easily been drawn from From Russia with Love, Goldfinger, <\/em>or Thunderball<\/em>. They also conclude the song with an electric guitar strumming an EmMaj9 chord, the so-called spy chord that Vic Flick plays at the end of the famous James Bond theme that started it all.<\/p>\n

Does this mean that \u201cNo Time to Die\u201d is the odds-on favorite to win? Perhaps, but it also seems to be overshadowed by another song, much as \u201cDos Oruguitas\u201d was. In this case, the song was written for a completely different Bond film and mostly functions as an Easter Egg for die-hard fans of the series.\u00a0 It is \u201cWe Have All the Time in the World,\u201d which was written by John Barry and Hal David and performed by Louis Armstrong over the end credits of On Her Majesty\u2019s Secret Service<\/em> (1968). Notably, the song appears just after Bond\u2019s new bride, Tracy, has been killed in a drive-by shooting by Blofeld and his assistant, Irma Bunt. It is yet another evocation of death in No Time to Die<\/em> with Tracy, like Vesper Lynd, implicitly included in the film\u2019s mounting body count. Notably Hans Zimmer\u2019s score for No Time to Die<\/em> incorporates the melody to \u201cWe Have All the Time in the World\u201d in three of the cues he wrote for the film. Indeed, long-time fans like me might well recognize the older Bond song in Zimmer\u2019s score much more readily than the new one specifically written for it.<\/p>\n

 <\/p>\n

Prediction for Best Original Song<\/strong><\/p>\n

\"\"<\/a><\/p>\n

An Oscar would confer EGOT status on Lin-Manuel Miranda, a distinction held by just a handful of other entertainment luminaries. In fact, because Miranda also won a Pulitzer Prize for Hamilton<\/em> and a MacArthur Genius Award, an Oscar would place him in entirely unique category. Say hello to the MacPEGOT.<\/p>\n

Yet, although an award for \u201cDos Oruguitas\u201d would make history, recent Oscar ceremonies have favored Bond songs. Adele won for \u201cSkyfall\u201d in 2013. Sam Smith repeated the feat with \u201cWriting\u2019s on the Wall\u201d in 2016. \u201cNo Time to Die\u201d also has already won a Grammy, a Golden Globe, and more than a dozen awards from prominent critics\u2019 societies. Eilish is also a newly minted pop star, whose personal story is the kind of underdog narrative that Oscar voters seem to like.<\/p>\n

If you are looking for a dark horse in the field, you might consider \u201cBe Alive.\u201d (Although when would you ever consider Beyonc\u00e9 a dark horse for anything?) But I am sticking with the favorite.\u00a0 On Sunday, I expect Eilish to win.\u00a0 It is the clubhouse leader in terms of the betting markets and also my personal favorite among the field.<\/p>\n

 <\/p>\n

An ode to the new cleffer<\/strong><\/p>\n

\"\"<\/a><\/p>\n

One of the first things you might notice about this year\u2019s slate of nominees for Best Original Score is the relative absence of the \u201cusual suspects\u201d in the music branch, such as Thomas Newman, Alexandre Desplat, or John Williams. Between them, these three composers have received a total of 78 nominations. Admittedly, only one of the five nominees this year \u2013 Germaine Franco \u2013 is a first timer. However, aside from Hans Zimmer\u2019s twelve previous nominations, none of the other composers has received more than four.<\/p>\n

Franco\u2019s nomination is significant for other reasons. In February, she became the sixth woman nominated for Best Original Score and the first Latina. The field has a decided international flair with nominees from Britain, Germany, and Spain joining two Americans.<\/p>\n

Of the five nominees, Alberto Iglesias\u2019 music for Parallel Mothers<\/em> (above and at bottom) comes closest to the style of a classical score. Yet it also presents a slight departure from those norms in its use of a chamber orchestra with most cues arranged for strings, piano, and the occasional wind instrument. Some feature the strident bowing style associated with Bernard Herrmann\u2019s famous score for Psycho<\/em> (1960). Others create lush combinations of strings and solo piano, an approach reminiscent of Frank Skinner\u2019s music for older Universal melodramas like All That Heaven Allows <\/em>(1956).<\/p>\n

If that sounds a bit odd, it shouldn\u2019t. Alfred Hitchcock and Douglas Sirk have been prominent influences on Pedro Almodovar\u2019s cinema over the years. Parallel Mothers <\/em>is the thirteenth film that Iglesias has scored for the great Spanish auteur. The composer admits that Almodovar\u2019s films are always rooted in melodrama. But Parallel Mothers<\/em> also had the generic trappings of a thriller, and his music strived to infuse scenes of psychological intimacy such that they crackled \u201cwith energy and light.\u201d Iglesias also sought to accentuate the protagonists\u2019 intertwined lives at a macro-level, using parallel musical structures to underscore how Ana enters and exits Janis\u2019 life at several points in the film.<\/p>\n

Iglesias is a four-time nominee and his score for Parallel Mothers <\/em>is among his best. But I fear this is not his year. Parallel Mothers<\/em> is among the biggest longshots in the Oscar betting markets not only for Iglesias in the Best Score category but also for Penelope Cruz as Best Actress. Moreover, the fact that Spain snubbed Parallel Mothers <\/em>when submitting its nominee for Best International Feature Film also doesn\u2019t bode well. Iglesias is once again a very deserving nominee whose work is likely to be overlooked in a highly competitive field.<\/p>\n

 <\/p>\n

Stretching the classical style: Incorporating novel idioms<\/strong><\/p>\n

\u00a0\"\"<\/a><\/strong><\/p>\n

Nicholas Britell earned his third Oscar nomination for Don\u2019t Look Up<\/em>, Adam McKay\u2019s acrid satire of contemporary politics and media. The film\u2019s dark humor and its apocalyptic conclusion undoubtedly posed a conceptual challenge for Britell. How do you preserve the comedic qualities of the story while still respecting the existential crisis that hints at larger issues around climate change, COVID, and the increasing distrust of science and medicine? As Britell acknowledges, he was \u201cunprepared for the wild ride\u201d that viewers experience over the course of the film.\u00a0 Britell\u2019s solution? A hyperbolic paean to science, a smattering of wacky electronic sounds, some rollicking big band jazz, and garage-band style Farfisa organ.<\/p>\n

In an interview with The Hollywood Reporter<\/em>, Britell notes that two cues were especially important in articulating the overall concept for the score.\u00a0 Even before production had wrapped, Britell created a demo cue entitled \u201cOverture to Logic and Knowledge\u201d<\/a> that McKay played on set to enable the cast to get in the right frame of mind.<\/p>\n

The piece unfolds as a canon performed on a piano that\u2019s been recorded with heavy reverb. After the statement of the initial theme, Britell interweaves additional voices in contrapuntal harmony, approximating the sort of mathematical precision one associates with Bach fugues. Afterward, Britell then tried to suss out what the opposite of that compositional style might be, eventually landing on big band jazz. The idiom is evident in the film\u2019s main title, which features walking bass, a simple brass and bass saxophone riff, and a soaring trumpet obligato. Another cue \u2013 \u201cIt\u2019s a Strange Glorious World\u201d<\/a> \u2013 reprises that big band style, yet further estranges the viewer from the serious global crisis dramatized in Don\u2019t Look Up <\/em>with the use of banjo and toy piano for instrumental color.<\/p>\n

Britell saves his most savage musical satire for a theme written for Peter Isherwell, the billionaire tech genius played by Mark Rylance.<\/p>\n

\"\"<\/a><\/p>\n

The composer arranges the theme for celestas, toy pianos, Farfisa organ, and bass synthesizers. These instrumental colors suggest Isherwell\u2019s childlike faith that new technology can solve all of humankind\u2019s biggest problems. Of course, Isherwell exudes this relentless optimism to mask his real intentions. Isherwell proposes a foolhardy mission to try and capture the streaking comet rather than deflecting or destroying it. He does so to feed his corporate greed as the comet possesses rare minerals that Isherwell hopes to harvest for use in his production of microchips.<\/p>\n

Britell\u2019s score displays incredible musical sophistication even as it is asked to underscore scenes that occasionally seem silly or in which the satire seems all too crude.\u00a0 That being said, I have some doubts that it will win for Best Original Score. This is not to gainsay Britell\u2019s extraordinary ingenuity in devising his music. Rather, it is just the brute reality that other films have better odds in what seems to be a close race.<\/p>\n

\"\"<\/a><\/p>\n

Germaine Franco\u2019s music for Encanto<\/em> also pushes the bounds of the classical score. In this case, though, it does so by incorporating various styles of Latin pop music rather than using big band jazz. To be sure, there was a strain of this type of composition in earlier eras, Think, for example, of the music written by Henry Mancini, Nelson Riddle, and Quincy Jones for films of the 1960s. That music, though, reflected the predominant Latin pop styles of the period, which included congas, rhumbas, cha-chas, sambas, and bossa novas.<\/p>\n

In contrast, Franco drew upon a different repertoire of Latin rhythms to fashion her score for Encanto<\/em>, including some folk music styles specific to the film\u2019s Colombian setting. These not only include more familiar idioms like salsa, but also more modern developments like reggaeton. The latter is a style that originated in Panama in the 1990s and mixes hip-hop beats with Jamaican riddims<\/em>. It rapidly spread through Spanish-speaking countries in the Caribbean.<\/p>\n

In Encanto<\/em>, reggaeton can be heard in Luisa Madrigal\u2019s big number, \u201cSurface Pressure.\u201d<\/a> The song, of course, was written by Lin-Manuel Miranda. Franco then incorporated the style into certain cues to ensure a strong sense of unity between the mood and vibe of the songs and those of the score.<\/p>\n

Other cues, however, are written in folk styles native to Colombia with Franco once again taking her cues from the rhythms of Miranda\u2019s songs. Encanto<\/em>\u2019s opener, \u201cThe Family Madrigal,\u201d is an up-tempo vallenato<\/em> song played in standard 2\/4 meter. It features marimba, three-button accordion, and guachara<\/em>, a Colombian percussion instrument played by rubbing a fork over a wooden, ribbed stick. Mirabel\u2019s \u201cI want\u201d song, \u201cWaiting on a Miracle,\u201d uses bambuco <\/em>rhythms. It unfolds in a fast triple meter characteristic of the idiom. As the only song featuring this rhythm, Miranda used it to further underline how Mirabel feels separated from her family due to her lack of a special gift for magic.<\/p>\n

Perhaps Franco\u2019s most important gesture, though, was using cumbia <\/em>rhythms to underscore Mirabel\u2019s movement. Cumbia <\/em>is popular style throughout South America but has its origins among enslaved African populations on the coasts of Colombia and different Caribbean nations. It uses a clave <\/em>rhythm common in Afro-Cuban music. As the style spread throughout Colombia in the early 1900s, musicians incorporated indigenous drums and wind instruments, including tambora, llamador, <\/em>and gaitas<\/em>. As Franco has noted in interviews, she uses the cumbia <\/em>to accompany Mirabel\u2019s first entrance into the \u201cCasita.\u201d From that point on, according to Franco, \u201cThe rhythm of the cumbia becomes the forward motion of her trying to find a solution to the problem.\u201d<\/p>\n

I suspect Franco\u2019s fellow composers in the music branch are as impressed as I am by her attention to details of rhythm and orchestration. To get the precise tone color needed for some of these Latin pop and folk styles, Franco had a special marimba native to the Choco rainforest region of Colombia disassembled and shipped to her in parts. After it was put back together, Franco played the marimba herself, two mallets in each hand.<\/p>\n

Encanto <\/em>isn\u2019t the favorite to take home the prize for Original Score. But if you\u2019re looking for a potential surprise on Sunday night, Franco seems to be in the best position to pull an upset.<\/p>\n

 <\/p>\n

Rock of the Westies<\/strong><\/p>\n

\"\"<\/a><\/p>\n

Many pop music fans know Jonny Greenwood from his work as a songwriter and lead guitarist in the British rock band, Radiohead. Greenwood, though, has also established a considerable reputation as a film composer. He is perhaps best known for his work with director Paul Thomas Anderson, who has collaborated with Greenwood on his past five projects. Beginning with There Will Be Blood <\/em>(2007), Greenwood went on to score The Master<\/em> (2012), Inherent Vice<\/em> (2014), Phantom Thread <\/em>(2018), and Licorice Pizza <\/em>(2021).<\/p>\n

In February, Greenwood earned his second Oscar nomination for Jane Campion\u2019s The Power of the Dog<\/em>. Much like the rest of the film, Greenwood\u2019s score works against many of the conventions of the classic Hollywood Western. Many studio-era oaters developed their scores around orchestrated versions of tunes in the cowboy songbook or around Coplandesque rhythms and harmonies. Both these approaches strived to evoke the majesty of the films\u2019 visuals, which often featured mountain vistas, endless prairies, and sunlit horizons.<\/p>\n

Instead of looking to the \u201csweeping strings\u201d style used in older Westerns, Greenwood was inspired by the atonal brass music that was used in old Star Trek <\/em>episodes to underscore the exploration of unknown planets. When Peter ventures into the mountains and discovers a dead cow, Greenwood accompanies these scenes<\/a> with a dissonant French horn duet to highlight the strange and forbidding quality this has on the impressionable teenager.<\/p>\n

Similarly, instead of a big string sound, Greenwood opted for smaller ensembles, occasionally writing things for six cellos or four violas. Greenwood also plucked strings of a cello as a correlate for Phil\u2019s onscreen banjo playing. Here again, the goal was to create a tone color that seemed just slightly off, emphasizing microtonal inflections to create a sound that was somber yet sinister.<\/p>\n

Phil\u2019s banjo playing also furnishes one of the most memorable scenes in The Power of the Dog<\/em>. Peter\u2019s mother, Rose, initially seems ill at ease after coming to live with George and Phil on the brothers\u2019 ranch. At one point, she seats herself at the piano and proceeds to struggle through a piano reduction of Johann Strauss Sr.\u2019s \u201cRadetzky March.\u201d Campion then cuts to Phil sitting in his bedroom offscreen. Phil then picks up the melody of the Strauss piece on his banjo, playing it almost effortlessly and improvising his own coda. In a test of wills, Phil\u2019s virtuosity humiliates Rose, who increasingly turns to alcohol to soothe her emotional wounds.<\/p>\n

\"\"<\/a>\u00a0 \"\"<\/a><\/p>\n

Because of this scene, Greenwood used a detuned mechanical piano <\/a>as a musical timbre associated with Rose.<\/p>\n

To produce this effect, Greenwood used computer software to create the sound of a piano roll for his pianola. Then, as the music was played back, Greenwood used a tuning wrench to slightly alter the pitches to create a sound akin to the honkytonk pianos scene in the saloons of older Westerns. For Greenwood, the sound proved perfect for Rose\u2019s character arc. As he states in an interview for Variety<\/em>, \u201cNot only is her story wrapped up in the instrument, but it was also a good texture for her gradual mental unraveling. I recorded hours of this stuff \u2013 poor Jane (Campion) had to hear quite a lot of it.\u201d<\/p>\n

Greenwood\u2019s modernist take on the typical Western score makes him one of the top contenders in this year\u2019s Oscars. Of course, it doesn\u2019t hurt that Greenwood wrote music for two other nominated films: Licorice Pizza <\/em>and Pablo Larra\u00edn\u2019s Princess Diana biopic, Spencer<\/em>. The betting markets have Greenwood as a longshot. However, since The Power of the Dog <\/em>leads the field with a dozen nominations in all, Greenwood could prevail in the event of a Dog <\/em>sweep.<\/p>\n

 <\/p>\n

Today\u2019s sounds for tomorrow\u2019s people<\/strong><\/p>\n

\u00a0<\/u>The last nominee for Original Score is the current favorite. Hans Zimmer earned his thirteenth Oscar nomination for Dune<\/em>, Denis Villeneuve\u2019s big budget adaptation of Frank Herbert\u2019s classic science-fiction novel. As Zimmer notes in a New York Times <\/em>profile, he self-consciously rejected the musical style associated with the Star Wars<\/em> series and its many imitators. Those scores looked to the past for inspiration, finding it in Gustav Holst, Igor Stravinsky, Erich Wolfgang Korngold, and even Benny Goodman. Instead, Zimmer set himself an almost impossible task, trying to create sounds that no one had ever heard before.<\/p>\n

The result is a score that Darryn King calls \u201cone of Zimmer\u2019s most unorthodox and most provocative.\u201d The composer reports that he spent days contriving new sounds, sometimes commissioning the construction of new instruments or using conventional instruments in extremely unusual ways to get the effect he desired. Although synthesizers keep the score rooted in Zimmer\u2019s pop music past, he combines these with several unusual sonorities that include Irish whistles, Indian bamboo flutes, and metallic scraping noises.<\/p>\n

Many of these instrumental choices are keyed to aspects of Dune<\/em>\u2019s intergalactic setting. The rumble of distorted electric guitars evokes the seismic shifts occurring beneath the desert sands on the planet\u2019s surface. Zimmer even used some of the environmental details to communicate what he wanted from the musicians performing on the soundtrack. Slide guitarist David Fleming reports that Zimmer told him for one cue, \u201cThis needs to sound like sand.\u201d<\/p>\n

\"\"<\/a><\/p>\n

Zimmer performed similar wonders in his use of other instruments. For the scene where the House of Atreides arrives on Arrakis, Zimmer recorded thirty bagpipes playing in a Scottish church. The added reverberance raised the volume of the ensemble to ear-splitting levels of 130 decibels. The highland players needed to wear earplugs to avoiding damaging their hearing. But Zimmer got the sound he wanted, the musical equivalent of a blaring air raid siren.<\/p>\n

Zimmer\u2019s desire to find new sounds not only altered the usual timbres of instruments but also of the voice as well. For Dune<\/em>, Zimmer engaged the services of music therapist and singer Loire Cotler. To create the qualities Zimmer was seeking, Cotler drew on several non-Western singing styles. Her syncretic method combined Jewish niggun, South Indian vocal percussion, Celtic lamentation, and Tuvan throat-singing. The end result was a hybridized style that sounded wholly unique: a war cry expressed as though it were an ancient antecedent of Esperanto. Cotler tried to find a name for the new vocal technique, ultimately settling for the person responsible; she called it the \u201cHans Zimmer.\u201d<\/p>\n

Perhaps Zimmer\u2019s most audacious gesture involved hiring winds player Pedro Eustache to build new instruments from scratch. Eustache created a 21-foot horn, a sort of modern version of the old animal horns fashioned into shofars and zinks during the Middle Ages. He also produced a contrabass version of the duduk, which King described as a \u201csupersize version of the ancient Armenian woodwind instrument.\u201d<\/p>\n

What does it all add up to? A score that hits all the right notes in transposing Herbert\u2019s imposing epic to the big screen. Zimmer\u2019s music is at times quietly menacing, somber and pensive at other moments, and brooding but anthemic for Dune<\/em>\u2019s big action scenes. Zimmer\u2019s score for Dune<\/em> does not depict the kind of triumphalism found in Star Wars<\/em> or other space operas. Rather, it opts to capture the elements of dark mysticism and doleful psychedelia that made Herbert\u2019s novel a literary head trip in the 1960s. To be sure, Zimmer\u2019s music doesn\u2019t concoct earworms to evoke the sandworms. Yet it succeeds admirably where others have failed nobly. (If you think this is easy, just watch and listen to David Lynch\u2019s misbegotten adaptation from 1984.)<\/p>\n

 <\/p>\n

Prediction<\/strong><\/p>\n

\"\"<\/a><\/p>\n

One could easily make the case for Germaine Franco to win for Encanto<\/em>. The score and the album have dominated the popular music scene ever since the film was released in late November. Yet Dune<\/em> stands a good chance at claiming several other craft awards, such as those for Sound and Production Design, which bodes well for Zimmer\u2019s chances on Sunday.<\/p>\n

In the world of film music today, the Burgomeister<\/em> of Bleeding Fingers Music casts a shadow over the field as large as any of the luminaries who preceded him like Ennio Morricone, Jerry Goldsmith, or Dimitri Tiomkin. When I contemplate the sheer number of innovations Zimmer made in the music he composed for Dune<\/em>, I can\u2019t bring myself to bet against him. I think Hans takes home the Oscar on Sunday. He\u2019ll walk away with another hunk of metal to scrape for the Dune <\/em>sequel.<\/p>\n

\n

Once again, I want to give a shout-out to Jon Burlingame for his excellent coverage of Hollywood and international film music for Variety<\/em>.\u00a0 As a subscriber, I always enjoy reading his work for the venerable trade journal, not just during awards season but year-round.<\/p>\n

The Diane Warren interview with USA Today<\/em> that I referenced can be found here<\/a>. Additional interviews with Deadline <\/em>and Gold Derby <\/em>are found here<\/a> and here<\/a>.<\/p>\n

Interviews with Lin-Manuel Miranda discussing the songs he wrote for Encanto <\/em>can be found here<\/a> , here<\/a>, and here<\/a>.<\/p>\n

Vulture<\/em> published a nice piece on the process of writing the title song for No Time to Die<\/em>, which can be found here<\/a>.<\/p>\n

Alberto Iglesias discusses with work with director Pedro Almodovar here<\/a> .<\/p>\n

Nicholas Britell talks about his work Don\u2019t Look Up <\/em>with Indiewire <\/em>and Variety <\/em>here<\/a> and here<\/a> . One can find several interviews with Germaine Franco about her process on creating the score for Encanto<\/em>. A sample can be found here<\/a>, here<\/a>, here<\/a>, and here<\/a>.\u00a0\u00a0 A movie score suite featuring Franco\u2019s themes for Encanto <\/em>can be found here<\/a>.<\/p>\n

Jonny Greenwood talks with Variety<\/em> about his collaboration with Jane Campion here<\/a> and here<\/a>.<\/p>\n

The indie-music website provides an interesting review of Greenwood\u2019s soundtrack for The Power of the Dog <\/em>here<\/a>.<\/p>\n

Finally, Darryn King\u2019s superb overview of Hans Zimmer\u2019s score for Dune<\/em> can be found here<\/a>.<\/p>\n

\"\"<\/a><\/p>\n

Parallel Mothers<\/strong><\/em><\/p>\n","protected":false},"excerpt":{"rendered":"

King Richard The Oscars are upon us again. The Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences may have decided that “Music (Original Score)” is one of the categories not important enough to show live along with the rest of the awarding of the golden statuettes. We, of course, think this is absurd. (Will the Oscar […]<\/p>\n","protected":false},"author":3,"featured_media":0,"comment_status":"closed","ping_status":"closed","sticky":false,"template":"","format":"standard","meta":{"footnotes":""},"categories":[186,1,46,57],"tags":[],"class_list":["post-48547","post","type-post","status-publish","format-standard","hentry","category-awards","category-film-comments","category-film-technique-music","category-hollywood-aesthetic-traditions"],"_links":{"self":[{"href":"https:\/\/www.davidbordwell.net\/blog\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts\/48547","targetHints":{"allow":["GET"]}}],"collection":[{"href":"https:\/\/www.davidbordwell.net\/blog\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts"}],"about":[{"href":"https:\/\/www.davidbordwell.net\/blog\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/types\/post"}],"author":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/www.davidbordwell.net\/blog\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/users\/3"}],"replies":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/www.davidbordwell.net\/blog\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/comments?post=48547"}],"version-history":[{"count":12,"href":"https:\/\/www.davidbordwell.net\/blog\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts\/48547\/revisions"}],"predecessor-version":[{"id":48584,"href":"https:\/\/www.davidbordwell.net\/blog\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts\/48547\/revisions\/48584"}],"wp:attachment":[{"href":"https:\/\/www.davidbordwell.net\/blog\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/media?parent=48547"}],"wp:term":[{"taxonomy":"category","embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/www.davidbordwell.net\/blog\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/categories?post=48547"},{"taxonomy":"post_tag","embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/www.davidbordwell.net\/blog\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/tags?post=48547"}],"curies":[{"name":"wp","href":"https:\/\/api.w.org\/{rel}","templated":true}]}}